Systemic change a must for ending Obstetric Violence

25.11.19

International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women - MMM issues a statement reiterating the urgency bringing an end to the mistreatment and violence mothers suffer in pregnancy and childbirth.

According to the Venezuelan Law, which was the first to define this type of violence, obstetric violence is the “appropriation of a woman’s body and reproductive processes by health staff, in the form of dehumanizing treatment, abusive medicalization and pathologisation of natural processes, involving a woman’s loss of autonomy and of the capacity to freely make her own decisions about her body and her sexuality, which has negative consequences for a woman’s quality of life.”

Obstetric violence includes physical and verbal abuse, as well as a lack of medical support from health care professionals during childbirth, unconsented medical procedures and the refusal to provide pain relief.

Harmful for the mothers, these practices also have an impact on the mother-child relationship and therefore on the child’s development and wellbeing: we know how toxic stress and violence can negatively impact early childhood development and jeopardize a child’s future

Therefore, it is crucial to promote respectful maternity care and the involvement of women and women’s groups in decisions concerning childbirth policies and practices in full compliance with the World Health Organization (WHO) recommendations on positive pregnancy and birth, and the UN OHCHR Report of the Working Group on the issue of discrimination against women in law and in practice.

In May this year and for the first time, the UN Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women, Ms. Dubravka Simonović gave the opportunity to all interested parties, including civil society, to submit reports documenting the situation women face across the world. 128 submissions were received and a report was drafted. MMM contributed by submitting two reports: a comparative report presenting the situation concerning obstetric violence in Europe and a report about the situation in Argentina (in Spanish).

In October 2019, Ms. Simonović presented her report, “A human rights-based approach to mistreatment and violence against women in reproductive health services with a focus on childbirth and obstetric violence”, to the General Assembly of the United Nations.

The Special Rapporteur’s report is a significant step in recognizing and giving visibility to this hidden issue, as it is the first report exposing obstetric violence at the international level. The evidence provided not only depicts the widespread reality of obstetric violence, but also how legislation, policies and healthcare providers can bring an end to such a detrimental epidemic.

The report addresses the various root causes of mistreatment and violence against women during childbirth such as: “discriminatory national laws that include spousal or third-party consent for women’s medical treatments”. It is essential that mothers become the primary consultant for consent during childbirth. Simonović also mentions the role of labour conditions in health systems that lead to this mistreatment during childbirth. To rectify the issue, she calls for, “cooperation between health institutions and professional associations with women’s non-governmental organizations.”

We are hopeful that Simonović’s report will make an impact on policymakers, as its content and data efficiently show the severity and extent of the issue, and the need for a systemic change to tackle it.

In addition, the medical journal Lancet released a study in November 2019 on childbirth in hospitals in different countries including Ghana, Guinea, Myanmar and Nigeria. In these countries, 35-40% of women on average experienced some kind of “physical abuse, verbal abuse, or stigma or discrimination”. It is important to note that women in this study documented that physical and verbal abuse peaked 30 minutes before birth and until 15 minutes after. Moreover, around 57% of women were not offered any pain relief in the hospital. Many women did not consent to episiotomy or cesarean section, despite receiving these procedures.

We call upon policymakers, health professionals and all actors involved to create an adequate framework including preventive measures to put an end to obstetric violence as well as putting in place a system that provides reparation and compensation to victims.

Read MMM’s full statement 

See also the MMM contribution to the 2019 Report of the UN Special Rapporteur on Eliminating Violence against Women on obstetric violence

 

 

Keywords:

Most read articles

Mothers march with a pen

20.11.19

Our education campaign launches at the London School of Economics (LSE).

Lire plus

Seminar on the role of families in the circular economy – 14 May 2019 EESC Brussels

15.04.19

Make Mothers Matter is organising in partnership with the European Economic and Social Committee a seminar on “the Role of Families in achieving the Circular Economy” on the occasion of

Lire plus

Work-Life-Balance: Eu Parliament voted the new Directive

05.04.19

The EU Directive on Work-Life Balance for parents and family carers gained a very large majority, in the European Parliament on the 4th of April 2019 (490 votes in favor,

Lire plus

Making social protection work for and with mothers

28.02.19

UN New York , 63rd Commission on the Status of Women - MMM Statement highlights that the 2 main pillars of social protection, health and income security, are particularly relevant

Lire plus
See all the articlesof the category

Latest News from MMM and its Network

Mothers march with a pen

20.11.19

Our education campaign launches at the London School of Economics (LSE).

Read more

How to engage consumers in the circular economy?

14.02.20

As part of #Circ4life, an EU Horizon 2020 Research Project, Make Mothers Matter conducted three consumer surveys in order to uncover how to better engage end-users in the circular economy.

Read more

Invitation – CSocD58 Side-event on single mothers and homelessness

14.02.20

UN New York, Commission on Social Development - to raise awareness of the specific vulnerability of single mothers in relation to homelessness and its impact on children.

Read more

Don’t talk to me about my mother

13.02.20

An op-ed by Roland Vaxelaire, MMM Board member, published in La Libre Belgique a daily newspaper in Belgium.

Read more

Parent education, a major challenge

25.01.20

UN New York - MMM Statement at the High-level interactive dialogue on the occasion of the International Day of Education reaffirms the essential role of parents in children's education and calls for policies to

Read more

Beijing+25 – Time to focus on unpaid family care work

16.01.20

UN New York, CSW64 - In a statement submitted ahead of the 64th Commission on the Status of Women, MMM highlights the specific perspectives of women in their role as mothers, and calls for policies that address

Read more

Single mothers need support, not stigmatization

15.01.20

UN New York, CSocD58 - In the written statement that it submitted ahead of the next session of the UN Commission on Social Development, MMM draws attention to single mothers’ specific vulnerability to poverty

Read more