Justice must not be blind to unpaid care

08.03.26

UN New York – MMM's written statement to the 70th UN Commission on the Status of Women (CSW70) argues that access to justice for women and girls remains fundamentally incomplete because legal systems systematically ignore unpaid care work. Despite caregiving being essential to families, communities, and economies, it is rarely treated as "real labour" in legal reasoning. This omission perpetuates injustice across divorce proceedings, property division, social benefits, and employment disputes, often leaving mothers economically disadvantaged or in poverty.

The Problem: Invisible Labour and Structural Barriers

Globally, women continue to shoulder a disproportionate share of unpaid domestic and care work, which limits their economic autonomy, educational opportunities, and public participation – in particular when they are mothers. In legal contexts, particularly during separation or divorce, courts typically prioritise monetary contributions over caregiving input.

Unpaid care is rarely accounted for in asset division, spousal support, or custody decisions. This devaluation communicates that care “does not count,” leading to economic insecurity and institutional mistrust.

These challenges are compounded by structural barriers: limited access to legal aid, lack of childcare during proceedings, and inflexible court schedules that ignore caregivers’ constraints. Women from marginalized communities – migrants, minorities, and those with disabilities – face compounded discrimination, making justice even more elusive.

International Frameworks vs. National Reality

Existing international instruments already support better justice systems for women. CEDAW General Recommendations call for legal systems to respond to gender-specific realities, recognise the economic value of unpaid care in marriage dissolution, and account for women’s unpaid contributions. Similarly, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) emphasizes special support for maternity and caregiving responsibilities.

However, national legal systems fall short. The World Bank’s Women, Business and the Law project reveals that women enjoy only 64% of the legal protections men do when childcare and safety indicators are included. Discriminatory laws persist: 86 economies restrict the types of jobs women can hold, 75 limit women’s asset management or inheritance rights, and 19 countries still allow husbands to legally prevent wives from working. These barriers erode women’s bargaining power in courtrooms and family disputes.

Promising Precedents: Spain and Colombia

Despite these gaps, promising reforms demonstrate what change looks like. In February 2023, a Spanish court awarded over €200,000 to a woman for 25 years of unpaid domestic and caregiving work during her marriage, calculating compensation using Spain’s minimum wage. This landmark ruling validates caregiving as a legitimate basis for financial compensation and aligns with CEDAW’s call to recognize non-financial contributions.

Additionally, framing care as a human right is gaining traction. In 2024, Colombia’s Constitutional Court recognized care as a fundamental right, and in August 2025, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights issued an Advisory Opinion, affirming care as an autonomous human right encompassing the right to care, to be cared for, and to self-care. This approach shifts care from a private responsibility to a collective one, obligating states to invest in public care infrastructure and guarantee accessible, affordable care for all.

MMM Recommendations

To strengthen access to justice for women, MMM calls on governments to:

  • Reform laws to integrate unpaid care work into divorce settlements, custody decisions, and spousal support calculations
  • Develop methodologies to quantify caregiving in legal terms, using international standards and precedents like the Spanish case
  • Train legal professionals in gender-sensitivity and care-awareness to address existing biases
  • Improve accessibility through childcare at courts, flexible hearing schedules, and expanded legal aid for unpaid caregivers
  • Integrate care into justice discourse, advocating for caregiving as a central basis for rights claims

 

Caregiving remains legally invisible despite its fundamental societal role. If justice systems continue to ignore unpaid care work, particularly in courtrooms and legislation, justice itself remains incomplete. Legal systems must recognize caregiving as essential, dignified, and worthy of legal protection to build truly just and inclusive societies.

Justice must not be blind to unpaid care. It must see caregiving as essential, dignified, and worthy of legal recognition. Only then can we claim to build just and inclusive societies.

 

Read the full statement: Submission with reference notes – UN Document

 

The 70th UN Commission of the Status of Women takes place 9-19 March 2026 at the UN Headquarters in New York. Its Priority theme: Ensuring and strengthening access to justice for all women and girls, including by promoting inclusive and equitable legal systems, eliminating discriminatory laws, policies, and practices, and addressing structural barriers

 

→ See also information on the MMM event on 11 March in New York on Parental Leave in Law and Practice: Enhancing Women’s Equity and Global Development

 

Most read articles

Europe Must Listen to Mothers: Our landmark report heads to the European Parliament

28.08.25

On 22 September 2025, the voices of mothers will take centre stage in Brussels. For the first time, Make Mothers Matter (MMM) will present its State of Motherhood in Europe

Lire plus

Belgian Mothers Face Alarming Rates of Burnout and Perinatal Depression, New EU Survey Finds

03.07.25

Belgian mothers are facing a mental health crisis. According to the State of Motherhood in Europe 2024 survey by Make Mothers Matter (MMM) and Kantar, Belgium reports the highest rates

Lire plus

Parental Mental Health Takes Centre Stage at the French National Assembly

02.04.25

Paris, France – On April 2nd, Make Mothers Matter was honoured to have key findings from its State of Motherhood in Europe 2024 report cited at the French National Assembly

Lire plus
See all the articlesof the category

Latest News from MMM and its Network

Invisible Violence: Why Mothers Must Be Recognised in the Fight Against Gender-Based Abuse

25.03.26

UN Geneva – Violence against women is widely acknowledged. Yet the specific forms of violence linked to motherhood remain largely overlooked. Drawing on grassroots evidence from across the globe, Make Mothers

Read more

Parental Leave: A Global Imperative for Gender Equity and Economic Prosperity

25.03.26

UN New York – At the event MMM organised on the margins of the 70th UN Commission on the Status of Women, experts and policymakers converged to argue that parental leave is far more than a workplace benefitâ€

Read more

Job Sharing: A Promising Solution for Working Mothers

24.03.26

By Ariane de Liedekerke, Network Co-ordinator, Make Mothers Matter While many women are still sidelined professionally after becoming mothers, leading to a lose-lose situation, some companies are testing new wa

Read more

Recognising Care
The Relevance of Parenting Skills in the EU Skill Portability Initiative

16.03.26

Make Mothers Matter (MMM) responded to the Public Consultation on the European Commission’s upcoming Skill Portability Initiative. We submitted a paper outlining our views and provided feedback on the need to

Read more

Hidden in Plain Sight: The Mental Health Crisis Facing Young Mothers in Europe

14.03.26

UN Geneva – An MMM submission to the OHCHR call for input on the impact of mental health challenges on the enjoyment of human rights by young people highlights a critical, often overlooked human rights issue:

Read more

Climate finance must prioritise mothers and care

13.03.26

UN Geneva – Responding to the OHCHR Call for inputs on Climate Financing and Human Rights MMM argues that climate finance must prioritise mothers, unpaid caregivers, and maternal health in order to be truly e

Read more